Goodfellas Old World Restaurant and Bar: #1 Pizza & Pasta Restaurant in the U.S.

New York Italian in the midst of the Midwest? Yes indeed, at Goodfella’s Old World Restaurant and Bar in McCordsville, Indiana, a suburb about ten miles northeast of Indianapolis. Word has it that not only is the pizza “New York Italian,” it was actually voted Best Pizza and Pasta restaurant in all of America for three years running, and some Goodfella’s fanatics want them to be recognized best in the entire world!

What’s all the fuss, you say? Then you haven’t been to a Goodfella’s. Solid service and even better food is the general consensus. As far as the pizza goes, most admirers agree the magic is in the dough, made with the special semolina flour, the ultimate crust is, well, the ultimate in crusts. There is a faction, though, that avers the Old World brick oven that gives birth to the perfect pies is the real secret.

Newspapers, magazines and television reviewers all sing the praises of Goodfella’s Old World Pizza and Pasta Restaurant. They go so far as to label a piece of Goodfella’s pizza “the slice of life.” Pizza alla Vodka, one of the signature slices from Goodfella’s brick oven, won even more laurels and the top cash prize for the unique 16-inch pizza pie from  New York’s finest and most knowledgeable pizza-makers. The vodka cream sauce with fresh mushrooms and homemade mozzarella, combined with Goodfella’s signature semolina and high-gluten flour, simply carried the judges away in fits of ecstasy.


Goodfella’s specializes in creating the perfect party or corporate event for any occasion. They have two party options for your convenience. People also love to hire Goodfella’s to cater their special occasion, and a Goodfella’s catered event is always abundant with wonderful food served in a professional and flamboyant style.

This Italian restaurant in McCordsville, shares the limelight with another branch in up-and-coming Carmel, Indiana, just 15 miles to the west. There are, however, only two other Goodfella’s Old World Restaurant and Bar locations, so far: one in Staten Island and one in, where else but New Jersey?

Hours of Operation:
Monday – Thursday, 11 am – 9 pm
Friday – Saturday, 11 am – 10 pm
Sunday, noon – 8 pm

Goodfella’s Old World Italian Restaurant and Bar
9641 Olio Rd
McCordsville, IN 46236

Goodfella’s Old World Italian Restaurant and Bar
13190 Hazeldell Pkwy
Carmel, IN 46033

Visit the Good Fella’s website

McCordsville Restaurants

Chicago’s Pizza Restaurant | Goodfellas Old World Restaurant and Bar | Wagon Wheel Eatery | McCordsville restaurants

Indianapolis Restaurants

Indianapolis Downtown Restaurants | Indianapolis North Restaurants | Indianapolis Northeast Restaurants | Indianapolis Northwest Restaurants | Indianapolis West Restaurants | Indianapolis Southwest Restaurants | Indianapolis East Restaurants | Indianapolis Southeast Restaurants | Indianapolis South Restaurants

Indiana Restaurants by City

Avon Restaurants | Brownsburg Restaurants | Carmel Restaurants | Danville Restaurants | Fishers Restaurants | Greenfield Restaurants | Greenwood Restaurants | Martinsville Restaurants | Mooresville Restaurants | Noblesville Restaurants | Plainfield Restaurants | Westfield Restaurants | Zionsville Restaurants | More Indiana Restaurants

Indianapolis Restaurants by Cuisine

American Cuisine Restaurants |Barbecue Restaurants | Cajun Restaurants | Chinese Restaurants | Delicatessen Restaurants | German Restaurants | Irish Restaurants | Italian Restaurants | Japanese Restaurants | Korean Restaurants | Mexican Restaurants | Pizza Restaurants | Seafood Restaurants | Steakhouses Restaurants | Thai Restaurants | More Indianapolis Restaurants by Cuisine